How the United States Became a Democracy

On July 4th, it is Interesting to Reflect on how Lucky we were.

Related Articles: Authoritarians and Economics, Silicon Valley and Fascism, How to Treat Protestors who turn Violent, Trump’s Birthday Parade, and The Supreme Court Ruling on Injunctions.

John Nixon reading the Declaration of Independence to the people in front of the State House immediately after its passage (Source: The New York Public Library Digital Collections).

The transformation of the United States from a collection of British colonies into the world's first large-scale modern democracy represents one of history's most significant political achievements. This revolutionary experiment in self-governance emerged through the convergence of several key factors: the foundational principles articulated in the Declaration of Independence, the constitutional framework that balanced power while protecting individual rights, the profound influence of Renaissance and Enlightenment thinkers, and George Washington's pivotal decision to establish peaceful transitions of power rather than monarchical rule.

The Declaration of Independence: Foundation of Democratic Ideals

The Declaration of Independence via the U.S. National Archives

The Declaration of Independence, adopted on July 4, 1776, established the philosophical foundation for American democracy by introducing revolutionary concepts that challenged traditional monarchical authority. Thomas Jefferson, drawing on the natural rights philosophy of the era, articulated the principle that "all men are created equal" and are "endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the pursuit of Happiness".

The Declaration's assertion that governments derive "their just powers from the consent of the governed" established the principle of popular sovereignty, fundamentally rejecting the divine right of kings. This concept meant that political authority emanated from the people rather than from monarchical or aristocratic privilege, creating the foundation for democratic legitimacy.

The document's emphasis on natural rights represented a departure from traditional British constitutional arguments, embracing universal principles that could apply to all peoples. As one analysis notes, "in the years just prior to independence, arguments based on the authority of the past began to diminish in favor of natural law arguments". This shift toward natural law provided the intellectual framework for justifying not only independence but also a new form of government based on consent rather than tradition.

Importantly, the Declaration served as more than a statement of independence—it became what Frederick Douglass called "saving principles" that would guide the nation's future development. The document's ideals established standards that the nation would struggle to fulfill, creating what scholars describe as a "promissory note" for expanding democracy to all Americans.

The Constitutional Framework: Balancing Power and Protection

The U.S. Constitution. Source: Pixaby

While the Declaration of Independence articulated democratic ideals, the Constitution of 1787 provided the practical framework for implementing democratic governance. The Constitutional Convention addressed the critical weaknesses of the Articles of Confederation, which had created a government too weak to function effectively.

Under the Articles, Congress lacked fundamental powers essential to governance: it could not tax, had no executive authority to enforce laws, possessed no national judiciary to resolve disputes, and required unanimous consent from all thirteen states to make amendments. These deficiencies became starkly apparent during events like Shays' Rebellion in 1786-87, when the national government proved incapable of responding to domestic unrest.

The Constitution addressed these problems by creating a federal system with three branches of government—legislative, executive, and judicial—each equipped with distinct powers and responsibilities. This structure implemented the principle of separation of powers, ensuring that no single branch could dominate the others while still providing effective governance.

The system of checks and balances embedded within the Constitution reflected the Founders' understanding that "ambition must be made to counteract ambition". As James Madison explained, this arrangement would provide "a double security [for] the rights of the people," as both the national and state governments would "control each other, at the same time that each will be controlled by itself".

The Constitution also addressed the challenge of governing a large, diverse republic. Madison argued that in a nation with "a multiplicity of interests," the rights of minorities would be protected because "the rights of individuals, or of the minority, will be in little danger from interested combinations of the majority". This insight helped resolve classical republican concerns about the viability of democratic government in large territories.

Renaissance and Enlightenment Influence: The Intellectual Foundation

The American founding drew heavily from Renaissance and Enlightenment thinkers who had developed new theories about government, natural rights, and the proper relationship between rulers and the governed. These intellectual influences provided the theoretical framework that made American democracy conceptually possible.

John Locke: emerged as perhaps the most influential philosopher for American democratic thought. Locke's theory of natural rights—life, liberty, and property—directly influenced Jefferson's formulation in the Declaration of Independence. Locke's concept of government by consent and his argument that people retained the right to overthrow governments that failed to protect their natural rights provided crucial justification for both the American Revolution and the establishment of democratic institutions.

Baron de Montesquieu: contributed the vital concept of separation of powers, which became a cornerstone of the American Constitution. Montesquieu's analysis of how dividing governmental authority among executive, legislative, and judicial branches could prevent tyranny directly influenced the Framers' design of the federal system. His work demonstrated how institutional arrangements could protect liberty while maintaining effective governance.

Voltaire: championed principles that would become central to American democracy, including freedom of speech, separation of church and state, and protection of civil liberties. His advocacy for religious tolerance and his attacks on arbitrary authority provided intellectual support for the First Amendment's protections of speech and religion.

Jean-Jacques Rousseau: contributed the concept of the social contract and the principle that legitimate government must reflect the "general will" of the people. Although the American system did not adopt Rousseau's model of direct democracy, his emphasis on popular sovereignty and the idea that people could only be free under laws they had consented to influenced American democratic theory.

These Enlightenment concepts challenged traditional notions of political authority and provided alternative models for organizing government. As one scholar notes, "the Enlightenment questioned authority and ordered for natural rights," creating intellectual tools that the American Founders could use to justify their revolutionary experiment.

George Washington's Democratic Precedent: Rejecting Monarchy

President George Washington via The Library of Congress Prints & Photographs Division

Perhaps no single decision was more crucial to establishing American democracy than George Washington's rejection of monarchical power and his commitment to republican governance. Washington's actions established critical precedents that ensured the survival of democratic institutions during the republic's vulnerable early years.

In 1782, Colonel Lewis Nicola wrote to Washington suggesting that he assume the title of king, arguing that only monarchical authority could provide the stability the new nation needed. Washington's response was swift and decisive, expressing that the suggestion caused him "painful sensations" and that such an action would be "the greatest mischief that could befall my country". Washington made clear that he had not fought against King George III only to become "King George I" himself.

This rejection of monarchy was not merely symbolic—it reflected Washington's deep commitment to republican principles. Historical analysis reveals that while Washington possessed the popularity and military authority to establish monarchical rule, he was "deeply dedicated to the principles of the Revolution and perceived monarchy as a regression".

Washington's most significant contribution to democratic precedent came through his actions rather than his words. On December 23, 1783, he appeared before the Continental Congress and, in a highly symbolic act, surrendered his military commission and returned to private life. This action, later immortalized in a painting that hangs in the Capitol rotunda, established him as an American Cincinnatus who "forsaking command, the military life, and a potential claim on executive, perhaps dictatorial, power".

Later, as president, Washington established the crucial precedent of voluntary relinquishment of power by choosing not to seek a third term. His Farewell Address in 1796 "cleared the way for the peaceful transfer of power from one President to another," establishing one of the fundamental characteristics of democratic governance.

These decisions were revolutionary in the context of world history. As one contemporary observer noted, Washington's actions meant that "there is not a king in Europe that would not look like a valet de chambre by his side". Washington's precedents ensured that American democracy would be based on the rule of law rather than the rule of individuals.

The Integration of Democratic Elements

The emergence of American democracy required the successful integration of these diverse elements into a functioning system. The Declaration provided the philosophical justification, the Constitution created the institutional framework, Enlightenment thought supplied the intellectual foundation, and Washington's precedents demonstrated that democratic ideals could be practiced rather than merely proclaimed.

Significantly, the Founders understood that they were creating something new in world history. As the Constitution's Preamble declares, the document was established by "We the People," emphasizing that sovereignty resided in the citizenry rather than in any individual or institution. This represented a fundamental departure from monarchical systems where authority flowed from the crown downward.

The Bill of Rights, added to the Constitution in 1791, further strengthened democratic protections by explicitly guaranteeing individual liberties including freedom of speech, press, religion, and assembly. These amendments ensured that the democratic system would protect minority rights and individual conscience against potential tyranny of the majority.

The American experiment also established federalism as a democratic innovation, creating a system where power was divided between national and state governments. This arrangement allowed for democratic participation at multiple levels while maintaining national unity and effectiveness.

Conclusion

The United States became a democracy through the convergence of philosophical innovation, institutional design, intellectual influence, and exemplary leadership. The Declaration of Independence established the principle that governments must derive their authority from popular consent rather than divine right or traditional privilege. The Constitution created a workable framework that balanced the need for effective governance with protection of individual rights through separation of powers and federalism.

Enlightenment thinkers provided the intellectual tools necessary to conceive of democratic alternatives to monarchy, while George Washington's precedents demonstrated that democratic principles could be successfully implemented in practice. Together, these elements created what one contemporary called "the first great modern democracy".

The American achievement was not merely the establishment of democratic institutions, but the demonstration that democracy could work on a large scale in a diverse society. As one analysis concludes, the Constitution was designed "to further the cause of liberty, not democracy" in the traditional sense, but in doing so, created a new form of government that combined democratic participation with protection of individual rights. This "liberal democracy" became a model that would eventually spread throughout the world, establishing the United States as the pioneer of modern democratic governance.

---

Notes: This is my own opinion and not the opinion of my employer, State Street, or any other organization. This is not a solicitation to buy or sell any stock. My team and I use a Large Language Model (LLM) aided workflow. This allows us to test 5-10 ideas and curate the best 2-4 a week for you to read. Rest easy that we fact-check, edit, and reorganize the writing so that the output is more engaging, more reliable, and more informative than vanilla LLM output. We are always looking for feedback to improve this process.

Additionally, if you would like updates more frequently, follow us on x: https://x.com/cameronfen1. In addition, feel free to send me corrections, new ideas for articles, or anything else you think I would like: cameronfen at gmail dot com.